Mini-project: Global Information Ecosystem (GIT) Report on Iran
Midterm Project, Spring 2022
Googlization of Knowledge: Information, Ethics, & Technology
Instructors: Linda Daniel, Hongyi Gong
Summary
This mini-project investigates Iran's information ecosystem, which includes the examination of its Internet, social media use, TV, radio, news, and relevant infrastructures.

Report
Background
The internet:
Iran’s access to the Internet started in 1993. The Internet World Stats (2021) shows that, until June 2021, Iran has 78 million Internet users out of the entire population consisting of 85 million people, with an Internet penetration rate of 91.8%. In fact, the penetration rate of Iran in 2017 was only 69%, and there were merely 250k Internet users back in 2000. In other words, Iran has been witnessing a sharp growth in Internet usage and development over the past years, the rate of which has been the highest among all the Middle East countries (Internet World Stats, 2021; OpenNet Initiative, 2009).
Benefiting from the rapidly developing infrastructures for Internet use, an increasing number of people have been participating in digital communication practices through the Internet, such as online discussions on social media. Web services such as Google and Instagram are widely used by Iranian people. According to Mazrooei, Sabahi, and Zanconato (n.d.), the construction and advancement of Iran's Internet infrastructure also arise from the country's need for "receiving and publishing news and debates on the current issues” responding to “the closure of outspoken and reformist newspapers” in Iran. Basically, the Internet has been the primary platform where Iranians discuss and voice their opinions, as well as where the authorities publish announcements and address specific issues. While in the meantime, the Iranian government adopts various policies and measures, such as limiting Internet access speed for households and Internet filtering, to restrict its citizens' access to web content. Online speech in Iran is also strictly monitored and controlled by the authorities.
Social media:
As mentioned above, Iran has a relatively high Internet penetration rate among its citizens. Most Iranian people have been using different online services. In Iran, Google has been the most widely applied search engine; Instagram has been the most frequently visited social media website (Alexa Internet, 2022). While, when it comes to social media platforms in general, Telegram has been the most popular messaging application as well as the top used social media platform (Mazrooei, Sabahi & Zanconato, n.d.). According to Media Landscapes, 71% of the social media users in Iran use Telegram, following which WhatApp ranks second and Instagram ranks third.
Since the 2000s, the Iranian authorities have been restricting Internet use in Iran, banning people’s access to certain web applications. Those web services include Facebook, YouTube, Twitter, and many other social media platforms and applications. In 2009, videos have been uploaded to those platforms recording how the country abuses its security forces against the people, the street demonstrations, and the violent oppression carried out by the government (Mazrooei, Sabahi & Zanconato, n.d.). With an increasing number of protests happening on the Internet, the government blocks those platforms within the Iranian domestic network. Another possible rationale, which was also given by the government to justify their behaviors, has been to ban the contents of pornography and anti-Islamism on the Internet.
Despite the ban from the government, people have been using VPNs and private servers to access blocked websites, such as Facebook. According to the Internet World Stats (2017), there were 40 million Facebook users out of the 56.7 million Internet users in Iran back in 2017. It seems obvious that the government is not fully capable of restricting people’s access to the Internet. Actually, the government also has official accounts on those social media platforms. While recently, the Iranian government announced its new measures, based on legislation named "Legislation to Protect Cyberspace Users," to ban social media platforms and web services in Iran (Sinaee, 2022). It is expanding the range of banned services that the citizens have access to, resulting in severe protests from the people.
TV:
First introduced to Iran in 1958, Television has been the main medium for Iranian people to receive news. IRIB, Islamic Republic of Iran Broadcasting, has national, provincial, and international channels provided through TV with eight foreign languages available (Mazrooei, Sabahi & Zanconato, n.d.). The contents are prepared for both people living in Iran and Iranian people living in other countries, and the categories of programs cover news, sports, science, documentary, etc. According to BBC (2021), the most-watched channel provided domestically is based on IRIB's Network Three, the contents of which are related to sports and entertainment.
Since 1994, satellite television has been restricted with equipment banned in Iran (Mazrooei, Sabahi & Zanconato, n.d.). Yet, despite the government’s strict censorship, foreign and international channels have been quite popular among Iranian people, and about 40% of the people were watching satellite channels back in 2010. Particularly, channels based on Persian have been gaining much popularity in Iran, among which BBC Persian has been the most received one. In 2014, the number of audiences for Persian BBC reached a maximum of 11.4 million people, and its contents include “news, art, science, culture, technology, and sport” (Mazrooei, Sabahi & Zanconato, n.d.).
Radio:
Same as TV, Radio broadcasting in Iran is also under the control of the IRIB (Mazrooei, Sabahi & Zanconato, n.d.). The IRIB possesses 12 radio stations specifically for domestic audiences and 30 radio channels for Iranian audiences outside Iran and international audiences. There also exist several radio broadcasts from other countries that are popular among Iranian audiences, such as Radio BBC in Farsi and Radio Farda. These channels are either under the censorship of IRIB or would encounter radio jamming from time to time (Milewski, 2008).
Newspapers:
Iran has approximately 100 newspapers that conduct daily publishment, mostly in Persian, with some significant English newspapers existing as well (Mazrooei, Sabahi & Zanconato, n.d.). With the Internet and web media developing rapidly, people read newspapers less frequently, while some of them remain influential. Most of these newspapers are about politics and news. Hamshahri and Jam-e Jam, two Persian newspapers possessed by Tehran Municipality and IRIB, are considered two best-selling papers of centrism, both of which possess circulations of around 50,000 a day. Keyhan and Resalat are two conservative Persian-language newspapers that are popular among Iranian people, with their circulations ranging from 10,000 to 20,000. In addition, Shargh has been the newspaper with reformist views published, which has reached a circulation of 20,000. Aside from Persian newspapers, Iran Daily and Tehran Times are two English papers that are widely known by Iranian people.
Analysis
The significant barrier to Iranian people's accessing information domestically is government control. For printed media, though the divergence of political opinions (e.g., centrism, conservatism) exists, all the domestically published newspapers and magazines are censored by the government. The Iranian government has been placing restrictions on the newspaper presses to control the opinions allowed to be published as well as the overall contents (Freedom House, n.d.). As for the broadcasting media, namely TV and radio, the state-owned institution of IRIB (Islamic Republic of Iran Broadcasting) has full control and monopoly over how people within the country access information through the two approaches. Although there also exist broadcasts and TV channels introduced from abroad, they are under the strict censorship of the authorities. Through normal approaches, people within Iran could only access TV and radio channels possessed by IRIB.
Such government control is not limited to traditional mass media. When it comes to digital media and social media platforms, the government has been enacting policies to restrict the citizens' use of the Internet, clearly employing the strategies of censorship, filtering, and surveillance. The authorities of Iran used to limit the household Internet speed for accessing multimedia contents, claiming that there was no need for people to use high-speed networks. Nowadays, the Iranian government has been constantly banning websites, Internet services, and social media platforms from outside Iran, including Facebook, YouTube, and Twitter. Besides, most of the websites that Iranian people could access without proxy or VPN are filtered by the government in the name of purifying pornography or eliminating anti-Islamic content. What is more, the government has strict control over the online speech of Iranian people, monitoring people’s speeches and opinions on the Internet. Based on all these factors, Iran has been “one of the most oppressive countries” ranking 174 out of 180 in the 2021 World Press Freedom Index (Reporters without Borders, n.d.).
Such a barrier has been exerting severe pressure on the Iranian people in different dimensions. On the one hand, people are incapable of "engaging in open and free private discussion” in this context (Reporters without Borders, n.d.). Despite the country’s claimed urge to enable its citizens to engage within an Internet space of freedom, creativity, and innovation, its censorship and surveillance have been prevented people from doing so. In previous years, there also exist cases of journalists being murdered, or people spreading certain messages being accused of crimes, for which it would be further difficult for people to freely discuss and share. On the other hand, such control is actually pushing people away to seek other approaches to access information. For broadcast media, despite the ban on satellite disks, people still prefer international channels on satellite TV channels. On the Internet, it has also been a common practice for Iranians to apply VPN to access those banned web contents. In this case, not only are the governmental policies lacking in effectiveness and efficiency, but they will result in outrage and great unsatisfactory from the people. This phenomenon would not necessarily be helpful to the country’s economic growth as well.
Last but not least, the government's control over every aspect of the citizen's life could definitely be deemed as not only a deprivation of freedom for the Iranian people but also a violation of their fundamental rights. In the country, democracy is robbed of from Iranian people, and they don’t even have the basic rights of expressing, discussing, and debating their own beliefs and preferences. Meanwhile, their access to information is tightly controlled and restricted, which disables people of Iran to compare and contrast information and judging on their own. Therefore, such blocks and restrictions are going to produce more inequality among different countries in the Internet era with people from different regions possessing divergent approaches and access to information.
References
Alexa Internet. (2022). Top sites in Iran. https://www.alexa.com/topsites/countries/IR
BBC. (2021, June 15). Iran profile - media. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-14542234
Freedom House. (n.d.). Iran - Freedom in the world 2022. https://freedomhouse.org/country/iran/freedom-world/2022
Internet World Stats. (2017). Iran. https://www.internetworldstats.com/me/ir.htm
Internet World Stats. (2021). Internet Usage in the Middle East. https://www.internetworldstats.com/stats5.htm
Mazrooei, A., Sabahi, F., & Zanconato, A. (n.d.). Iran. Media landscapes. https://medialandscapes.org/country/iran
Milewski, T. (2008, Aug 27). Listening to Iran. CBC News. https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/listening-to-iran-1.739005
OpenNet Initiative. (2009). Iran. https://opennet.net/research/profiles/iran
Reporters without Borders. (n.d.). Iran - 2021 World Press Freedom Index. https://rsf.org/en/iran
Sinaee, M. (2022, Feb 23). Iranians outraged by government steps to limit Internet access. Iran International. https://www.iranintl.com/en/202202231490